(not from 2026 but there is a need to round out the past year with a few reviews of the December movies)
There was always going to be pressure on Wicked: For Good. Following a first part that surprised many with its scale, confidence, and emotional pull, expectations were high for a conclusion that could match — or even surpass — what came before.
Why this matters is simple: Wicked isn’t just another musical adaptation. It’s a cultural touchstone for theatre fans, and Part Two needed to land not only as a film, but as the second half of a story people already know by heart.
A Familiar Shape, for Better and Worse
Structurally, For Good does what the stage version does. It follows the same emotional arc, leans into consequence rather than discovery, and moves its characters toward inevitability rather than surprise.
In that sense, it’s faithful — perhaps too faithful. Where Part One felt expansive and cinematic, this instalment feels more restrained, almost boxed in by what it needs to resolve. That isn’t a failure of craft, but it does limit the sense of momentum.
Songs That Don’t Linger
One of the biggest differences is musical impact. While the first film delivered songs that lingered long after the credits, this time fewer numbers truly stick.
They work in the moment, and they serve the story, but they don’t quite embed themselves in memory. That may be true to the stage show — where Act Two is often considered musically weaker — but film has a higher bar for repeat emotional pull.
As a viewer, you’re engaged, but rarely floored.
Better Together Than Apart
Seen in isolation, For Good feels like a step down. But viewed alongside Part One, its value becomes clearer.
This is a second movement, not a standalone spectacle. Its purpose is to complete themes rather than introduce them, to resolve relationships rather than dazzle with novelty. When the two films are watched together, the emotional logic holds — and the story feels whole.
Reflection
Perhaps the disappointment comes less from what For Good is, and more from what Part One led us to hope it might be.
As a conclusion, it’s solid. As a film on its own, it’s less memorable. But maybe Wicked was always meant to be judged as a pair — not by how loudly it ends, but by how completely it tells its story.
